Satire, Sarcasm, and Irony- Why can’t the Conservative Right do it intentionally?

Posted on July 12, 2012. Filed under: Atheism, Atheist Ethics, Humour, Irony in the Title, Personal, Politics, Religion, Social Justice |


Meta-Irony and my Infinite Gladness

So this graphic popped up on my Facebook feed today:

I commented on the irony of it all, which prompted one of my conservative friends to ask me if I couldn’t recognize satire.  Oh, I recognize satire alright.  Only, this isn’t it.

See, satire is supposed to be ridiculing an opposing position.  It is supposed to make the plain reading of the text absurd.  I don’t get that here.  I get that it is supposed to be sarcastic (clue:  a reference to “gay ideology”)- I also think it misses the mark.  There is nothing particularly absurd about telling Christian kids that their bible based views are not sacrosanct.

In this case the author of this graphic attempted to use sarcasm as a tool to ridicule people who refuse to give special privilege to ideas because they stem from fundamental Christianity. They attempted to use satire by mocking the It Gets Better campaign launched by Dan Savage.  It may seem to be sarcastic (and satire) to a fundamentalist Christian, but it strikes me as a form of meta-irony, where the sarcasm actually paints a relatively positive spin on the very issue (s)he was trying to skewer.  So if it is satire, it is horribly ineffective.  Even as sarcasm it misses the mark to a non-myopic audience.

It is ironic because the author meant to use sarcasm and instead ended up coming up with a pretty good idea.  It is probably in the interests of everyone to educate young Christians that once they exit the bubble of a public school system that walks on egg shells and a social circle their parents have some control over- they will be mocked, vilified, marginalized and ridiculed.  It would be positive for all of us if they went into the world understanding that religion is no excuse for sloppy logic, gross generalizations, and Bronze-Age morality.

But I only said ‘God doesn’t suffer a woman to teach’!- I’m just following the bible“- is not going to cut it in the real world.  “Any man who lies with a man as he does with a woman is an abomination and should be put to death” – is totes fine if you happen to be with your fellow Christian brothers, but it won’t win you brownie points in the office staff room.  The real world is waiting.  The rational world is waiting…..

Maybe we ought to think about telling them that “It Gets Worse”



Make a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

7 Responses to “Satire, Sarcasm, and Irony- Why can’t the Conservative Right do it intentionally?”

RSS Feed for Misplaced Grace Comments RSS Feed

Distilled to it’s essence, the point of that poster seems to be: “People outside of your immediate peer or social group will sometimes vehemently disagree with you, especially if they perceive your views as racist, sexist, homophobic, or otherwise bigoted.”

How is that satire or sarcasm? It sounds like a valuable lesson that all kids should learn.

But seriously though, life isn’t particularly rough for Bible-thumping adults. Like anybody else, they tend to surround themselves in a little bubble filled with people who generally share their values and opinions.

Want to really experience ridicule? Try living as a transsexual. I had a pre-op transsexual coworker once, who was living as a female for a year before she got her sexual reassignment surgery. I would wish her experiences during that year on my worst enemy (and I’m ashamed to say I didn’t help much at the time, being a young man who wasn’t confident enough in my own sexuality to not fear being branded “queer” myself if I was seen being friendly to that coworker).

Dammit. My kingdom for a preview option! (not that it would have necessarily helped me find this error)

Of course I meant I would NOT wish my transsexual coworker’s experiences on even my worst enemy.

I’ve been watching you comment on a crazy x-tian blog (John Barron)- I’m a fan (yours, not the crazy x-tians)

Thanks. I appreciate the kind words. I apologize for being an infrequent blogger of late- several personal factors have made it nearly impossible to make blogging a priority. Stay tuned, I may be a more frequent blogger soon enough….

because they don’ t have a sense of humour or the IQ to put off sarcasm or irony

they can’t laugh at themselves or other things

and that’s a sign of mental illness

Meh. The usual “Oh poor us being persecuted for righteousness!” schtick. No, you’re being “persecuted” (ie: ridiculed and marginalized, mostly) for saying stupid, bigotted and harmful-to-innocent-others things. Deal — or consider that, maybe, you’re just plain *wrong*.

Reblogged this on dyke writer and commented:
Hi George!

it’s Nina.

I lost the passwords to my old account and have started a blog with a more writerly focus

just wanted to share this

i haven’t repaired my irony metre yet, so had to share this

Where's The Comment Form?

Liked it here?
Why not try sites on the blogroll...

%d bloggers like this: